At first glance, it can be hard to differentiate between top auto insurance companies. Well-known insurers like Allstate, Geico, Progressive and State Farm all have large market shares with broad policy options, competitive rates and personalized features. Despite their familiar names and extensive marketing, each company has its own perks and drawbacks. This guide can help you choose between these top carriers.
Comparing top car insurance companies
Finding the best car insurance for your needs can be challenging. To simplify your decision, Bankrate compared Allstate, Progressive, Geico and State Farm based on their policy offerings, rates, customer experience and third-party ratings for financial stability and claims satisfaction. Each company’s performance in these categories determined its overall Bankrate Score, with a maximum of 5 out of 5. We also analyzed 2024 claims satisfaction scores from J.D. Power to give you an idea of how satisfied customers are with each carrier’s service.
| Company | Bankrate Score | J.D. Power Claims Satisfaction Study | Avg. annual full coverage premium | Avg. annual full coverage premium after speeding ticket | Avg. annual full coverage premium after at-fault accident |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geico | 4.4 | 692/1,000 | $2,107 | $2,648 | $3,014 |
| Progressive | 4.4 | 672/1,000 | $2,418 | $3,120 | $3,647 |
| State Farm | 4.3 | 710/1,000 | $3,060 | $3,472 | $3,810 |
| Allstate | 3.9 | 691/1,000 | $3,081 | $3,597 | $4,237 |
Geico: Best for discounts
Why we chose it: On top of low average car insurance rates, Geico’s long list of discounts could make your policy even cheaper. Advertised discounts include savings for safe driving, emergency deployment, good students and affiliation groups. Geico tied for a 2024 Bankrate Award for Best Budget Auto Insurance Company, but it did come in below the segment average in the J.D. Power study, which may be a concern for drivers who value top-notch customer service.
Progressive: Best for safe drivers
Why we chose it: Progressive’s Deductible Savings Bank is an optional feature that rewards safe driving with potential savings on your deductibles. With this feature, drivers can earn a $50 credit toward their comprehensive and collision deductibles for each claim and violation-free policy period. Although not available in every state, this optional add-on could help drivers save money after an accident.
State Farm: Best for a driver with a ticket or accident
Why we chose it: Based on our study of average annual premiums, State Farm’s premium increases after a speeding ticket or at-fault accident were not as high compared to some other car insurance companies. Although these are estimates only and individual rates may vary, this could be a good sign for drivers with an existing mark on their record or who feel concerned about premium increases after an incident. State Farm also offers its Drive Safe & Save usage-based telematics program to help build safer driving habits and potentially earn a bigger discount on car insurance.
Allstate: Best for new and young drivers
Why we chose it: Adding a new young driver to your car insurance policy can be expensive, but Allstate offers various options to help reduce the cost. The Smart Student discount allows unmarried drivers under 25 to save if they meet one of these requirements:
- Maintain a grade average of B- or higher, or have a GPA of 2.7 or above
- Successfully complete the teenSMART driver education program
- Attend school at least 100 miles away from where their car is garaged
Depending on state availability, they can also enroll in Allstate’s Drivewise, a telematics program that tracks and rewards safe driving habits.
Allstate vs. Geico vs. Progressive vs. State Farm
The best car insurance company for you will depend on ratings factors and coverage needs. Comparing personalized quotes can help you find the cheapest carrier for you, but the cheapest company may not always be the best. This list of carrier pros and cons may help you further narrow down your search:
Allstate
Pros
- Offers a variety of policy add-ons like rideshare coverage, accident forgiveness and extended vehicle care
- Multiple rewards for safe driving
Cons
- Car insurance rates may be higher than other insurance carriers
- Scored below average in most regions of the 2024 J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study
Geico
Pros
- Competitive average premiums
- Tied for Best Car Insurance Company Overall in the 2024 Bankrate Awards
Cons
- Fewer local offices with agents, limiting personalized service
- Scored below average in the 2024 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study
Progressive
Pros
- Name Your Price tool lets customers create policies that fit their budgets
- Won the 2024 Bankrate Award for Best Auto Insurance Company for High-Risk Drivers
Cons
- Fewer local agencies compared to traditional carriers
- Ranked near the bottom in the 2024 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study
State Farm
Pros
- Offers an extensive network of local agents for personalized service
- Car insurance rates after accidents and speeding tickets tend to be more competitively priced
Cons
- May not write policies for drivers with DUIs
- Does not offer gap insurance on auto policies
Frequently asked questions
Methodology
Bankrate utilizes Quadrant Information Services to analyze November 2024 rates for all ZIP codes and carriers in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Rates are weighted based on the population density in each geographic region. Quoted rates are based on a single, 40-year-old male and female driver with a clean driving record, good credit and the following full coverage limits:
- $100,000 bodily injury liability per person
- $300,000 bodily injury liability per accident
- $50,000 property damage liability per accident
- $100,000 uninsured motorist bodily injury per person
- $300,000 uninsured motorist bodily injury per accident
- $500 collision deductible
- $500 comprehensive deductible
To determine minimum coverage limits, Bankrate used minimum coverage that meets each state’s requirements. Our base profile drivers own a 2022 Toyota Camry, commute five days a week and drive 12,000 miles annually.
These are sample rates and should only be used for comparative purposes.
Incidents: Rates were calculated by evaluating our base profile with the following incidents applied: clean record (base), at-fault accident and single speeding ticket.
Bankrate Scores
Our 2024 Bankrate Score considers variables our insurance editorial team determined impacts policyholders’ experiences with an insurance company. These rating factors include a robust assessment of each company’s product availability, financial strength ratings, online capabilities and customer and claims support accessibility. Each factor was added to a category, and these categories were weighted in a tiered approach to analyze how companies perform in key customer-impacting categories.
Each category was assigned a metric to determine performance, and the weighted sum adds up to a company’s total Bankrate Score — out of 5 points. Our scoring model provides a comprehensive view, indicating when companies excel across several key areas and highlighting where they fall short.
- Tier 1 (Cost & ratings): To determine how well auto and home insurance companies satisfy these priorities, average quoted premiums from Quadrant Information Services (if available), as well as any of the latest third-party agency ratings from J.D. Power, AM Best, Demotech and the NAIC, were analyzed.
- Tier 2 (Coverage & savings): We assessed companies’ coverage options and availability to help policyholders find a provider that balances cost with coverage. Additionally, we evaluated each company’s discount options listed on its website.
- Tier 3 (Support): To encompass the many ways an auto insurance company can support policyholders, we analyzed avenues of customer accessibility along with community support. This analysis incorporated additional financial strength ratings from S&P and Moody’s and factored a company’s corporate sustainability efforts.
Read the full article here
