Most Popular Halloween Candy of 2025: What Trick-Or-Treaters Really Want

Halloween is just around the corner, and it’s time to stock up on candy for those trick-or-treaters. But no one wants to overspend or be known as the house with the sub-par treats. We’ve got you covered with tips on how to save money on candy while still offering the most popular choices this year.

Popular Halloween Candy for 2025

Before diving into the data, keep in mind that national trends show a shift: shoppers are choosing more non-chocolate, fruity, and gummy candies this season. At the same time, classic chocolate favorites remain strong. According to national ordering data, the top picks for 2025 are:

• Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups – still firmly at the top of the list.
• Snickers – also in the top five nationally.
• Fruity/gummy front-runners: Sour Patch Kids, Skittles, and HARIBO Goldbears are seeing strong growth in 2025.

State-by-State Dynamics

While national trends are helpful, local preferences still matter if you want your house to be the “go-to” spot on the block. Each U.S. state has its own favorite candy.

Want to see what the favorite in your state is? Here’s a comprehensive list state-by-state, according to DoorDash’s 2024/2025 ordering data.

1. Alabama: Sweet Smiles
2. Alaska: Nerds
3. Arkansas: Sweet Smiles
4. Arizona: Red Vines
5. California: Snickers
6. Colorado: Haribo Gummies
7. Connecticut: Sour Patch Kids
8. Delaware: Reese’s
9. Florida: Skittles
10. Georgia: Trolli Gummies
11. Hawaii: Cadbury
12. Idaho: Red Vines
13. Illinois: Twizzlers
14. Indiana: Reese’s
15. Iowa: Laffy Taffy
16. Kansas: Sweet Smiles
17. Kentucky: Reese’s
18. Louisiana: Sweet Smiles
19. Maine: Reese’s
20. Maryland: Snickers
21. Massachusetts: Airheads
22. Michigan: Twizzlers
23. Minnesota: Laffy Taffy
24. Mississippi: Sweet Smiles
25. Missouri: Twizzlers
26. Montana: Red Vines
27. Nebraska: Laffy Taffy
28. New Hampshire: Reese’s
29. New Jersey: Reese’s
30. New Mexico: Sweet Tarts
31. New York: Twizzlers
32. Nevada: Snickers
33. North Carolina: Hershey’s Chocolate Bar
34. North Dakota: Reese’s
35. Ohio: Twizzlers
36. Oklahoma: Sweet Tarts
37. Oregon: Reese’s
38. Pennsylvania: Twizzlers
39. Rhode Island: Trolli Gummies
40. South Carolina: Hershey’s Chocolate Bar
41. South Dakota: Sweet Tarts
42. Tennessee: Sweet Smiles
43. Texas: Trolli Gummies
44. Utah: Sweet Tarts
45. Washington: Twix
46. West Virginia: Reese’s
47. Wisconsin: Twizzlers
48. Wyoming: Reese’s
49. Vermont: Reese’s
50. Virginia: Reese’s

Holiday Spending

This year, spending on Halloween is expected to set a new record: about $13.1 billion is projected for 2025, with candy spending alone nearing $3.9 billion. With that in mind, staying on budget is more important than ever.

Saving Money on Candy

Here are smart ways to balance being generous with trick-or-treaters while keeping your finances in check:

• Buy in bulk: Purchasing candy bags or large packs often gives you the best cost-per-piece price.
• Discount stores and late deals: Keep an eye on discount chains or last-minute markdowns (just make sure the candy still looks fresh).
• Portion control: Rather than handing out full-size bars (unless that’s part of your plan), you might give one piece per kid — plenty of households do this to balance cost and generosity.
• Mix popular with value picks: Stock enough of the top candies (Reese’s, M&M’s) to satisfy most, and fill in with a good, affordable candy you like.
• Know when to buy: Shopping early or right when seasonal candy hits shelves may give you access to better deals. Waiting too long might lead to higher mark-ups or fewer choices because the best stuff is already taken.

Make Smart Choices

With these tips in mind, you can make smart choices while buying Halloween candy. Aim to have a mix of bestselling chocolates plus some fruity/gummy options (since those are rising). Match your purchases with what’s trending nationally and what’s likely popular locally, so you’re prepared for the crowd at your door. You don’t have to break the bank to join in on the Halloween fun and maintain your financial well-being. Happy Halloween — and may your candy bowl be the envy of the neighborhood!

What to Read Next

• What Kind of Halloween Candy Is The Cheapest in 2025?
• 7 Ways To Throw a Great Halloween Party for Less Than $200
• 12 Places Where You Can Still Find Cheap Halloween Costumes
• 5 Places to Get Free Pumpkins for Halloween
• 10+ Cheap Halloween Costumes You Can Make in Minutes