Pick up any bestselling personal finance book, and you’ll find advice on budgeting, debt payoff, retirement planning, and maybe even investing in real estate. But flip through the pages, and you’ll likely notice one glaring omission: mental health. You’ll find tips on how to make a spreadsheet, but none on how to cope with the crushing shame that often comes with money mistakes. You’ll get a motivational quote or two, but not a single line about how anxiety, ADHD, depression, or trauma might sabotage your ability to follow any of the advice.

Why is this critical link between mental health and financial well-being almost completely ignored?

It’s not that the connection isn’t real. Study after study shows that our mental state influences the way we earn, spend, save, and think about money. Yet, in the world of personal finance, emotional and psychological struggles are rarely acknowledged, let alone addressed. And that silence can have devastating consequences for those who feel broken for not being able to “just budget better.”

Let’s break down why this topic remains taboo in finance books—and what happens when we pretend mental health doesn’t impact your money decisions.

Why Personal Finance Books Don’t Talk About Mental Health

Mental Health Is Deeply Intertwined with Financial Behavior

Mental health doesn’t just affect how you feel. It affects what you do. Anxiety can lead to decision paralysis. Depression can drain the motivation to check your bank account, let alone plan for the future. ADHD can make it difficult to follow through with routines, and trauma can warp your relationship with money entirely.

These challenges often result in missed payments, overspending, impulse purchases, and difficulty saving or planning ahead. Not because someone is lazy or careless, but because their brain is overwhelmed or wired differently. Yet most finance books treat these behaviors as moral failings instead of neurological or emotional responses.

This disconnect creates shame. A reader who already feels anxious or depressed might now also feel like a failure for not living up to the tidy budgets or debt snowball plans presented as universally achievable.

Finance Books Sell Simplicity, Not Complexity

One reason personal finance books avoid mental health is that it complicates the narrative. Simplicity sells. “Just stop buying lattes,” “Pay yourself first,” or “Follow this 4-step plan” are clear, digestible, and easy to brand. Mental health, on the other hand, is messy. It doesn’t fit into a formula. It varies by person and changes over time. There’s no one-size-fits-all solution, and that makes it harder to package as a bestseller.

Authors often assume their readers are rational actors capable of following instructions. But that assumption erases the millions of people for whom money struggles are not just logistical but emotional, psychological, or neurological. When the book ignores that reality, the reader is left feeling broken instead of supported.

Finance advice should meet people where they are, not where a spreadsheet says they should be.

The Shame Spiral: When Money Problems Fuel Mental Health Issues

Here’s the trap no finance book talks about: money issues don’t just stem from mental health struggles. They also make them worse. Being in debt can create chronic stress. Struggling to keep up with bills can trigger feelings of failure. Being unable to provide for your family can destroy your sense of worth. Over time, the anxiety becomes depression, the shame becomes paralysis, and the spiral deepens.

When a personal finance book fails to address this, it risks compounding the problem. A reader with depression who can’t keep up with their budget might internalize the failure and sink further into hopelessness. A person with bipolar disorder might feel even more isolated when their impulsive spending isn’t even acknowledged as a possibility. Ignoring mental health doesn’t neutralize it. It amplifies the damage.

Emotional Spending Is Treated Like a Sin, Not a Signal

Many finance books approach emotional spending like a moral weakness. “You just need more discipline,” they say. “Stop using money to cope.” But emotional spending isn’t just a bad habit. It’s often a symptom of something deeper.

People spend emotionally for a reason. It may be to self-soothe, to escape, to feel in control, or to temporarily silence anxiety. Telling someone to stop spending without addressing why they’re doing it is like telling someone with insomnia to “just go to sleep.” It’s dismissive, unrealistic, and ultimately harmful.

Instead, personal finance advice needs to start treating emotional spending as a red flag, not a character flaw. It should invite the reader to explore what their money behavior is trying to tell them, because money doesn’t just move through your hands. It moves through your mental state.

Trauma Shapes Our Relationship with Money, And It Rarely Gets Mentioned

Financial trauma is real. Whether it’s growing up in poverty, experiencing eviction, losing a job, or surviving financial abuse, these experiences leave scars. They change the way you perceive security, risk, and self-worth. For many people, trauma wires them for financial hypervigilance or self-sabotage, often without them realizing it.

And yet, most personal finance books treat every reader like a blank slate—someone with no emotional history attached to money. That’s not only naive. It’s damaging. Trauma-informed financial advice is rare but desperately needed.

We need financial resources that don’t just ask, “What’s your credit score?” but also, “What did money feel like growing up?” or “How did financial instability shape your sense of safety?” Those are the conversations that help people heal, not just the budget.

Mental Health Care Itself Is a Financial Burden

Ironically, one of the biggest costs ignored in finance books is the cost of getting mental health care itself. Therapy is expensive. Medication can be costly. Time off work to deal with burnout or panic attacks? Unpaid, in many cases.

So when a personal finance book gives generic advice like “cut expenses,” it often ignores the fact that for many people, mental health treatment is already straining their budget. And without addressing those root issues, no amount of budgeting or side hustling is going to lead to long-term financial stability.

Financial plans that don’t account for the emotional cost of mental survival are incomplete. Health, including mental health, is a financial issue, too.

What Needs to Change in Personal Finance Advice

It’s time for personal finance authors, educators, and influencers to acknowledge that money and mental health are inseparable. That means:

• Normalizing financial anxiety, depression, and ADHD in financial discussions
• Encouraging therapy and mental health care as part of a financial wellness plan
• Shifting language away from “discipline” and “failure” toward compassion and context
• Addressing the real emotional reasons behind spending habits
• Encouraging readers to explore their money stories and financial trauma

Only then will financial advice truly be for everyone, not just the neurotypical, emotionally well, spreadsheet-ready few.

So what do you think? Should personal finance books start including mental health in their advice—or is that too much to ask from a spreadsheet?

Read More:

Five of My Favorite Personal Finance Books

How to Fix Your Finances in 30 Days—Even If You’re Starting From Zero

Read the full article here